WIND POWER PAGE

Picture
Wind power is everywhere, but it's not always as welcome as the sun. Accordingly, efforts to tap wind power often get a frosty reception. Wind power also has a much higher energy potential making it one of the more controversial forms of alternative energy. You don't have to look far to see battles brewing over this blustery subject, any which way the wind blows.

  <')((((((((><~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Winds Story Deflates Under Herald Head 01.25.10

Picture
Tabloids should just stay away from science stories. Case in point, this Boston Herald headline bellowing about the “Big Secret” in the Cape Wind windfarm project: millions, in “Hidden Costs.” The story cites the “hidden costs” that cropped up in a similar windfarm plan farther south to support the hysterical headline. That southern windfarm, according to the Herald, will add about $20 to the average annual electric bill in that area. Are we to assume then that these hidden costs in Cape Wind will translate into $20 annually for Bay State rate payers?


Somehow, “hidden millions” sounds a lot worse than “$20 annually.” Is the Herald deliberately distorting the story in the headline to sell papers? Perish the thought! Reading deeper, clearly the story is more tepid than the headline prompting you to read it. It goes on to point out that the hidden millions estimate is also based on unusually low natural gas prices this winter driving the windfarm's comparative power price higher. The story also notes that because the windmills tap a renewable source of energy, the prices of that wind energy will only go down over time while natural gas-generated energy prices will only rise. No mention of the fact that the windfarm will also be less polluting. Hey, if the headline doesn't draw you in, you don't read the story. And, despite the headline, it's a good story.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~><((((((((()'>

While we're on the subject of windfarms here's an article saying wind power could replace 20 to 30 percent of the world's oil use. However, all that wind power will do less than previously thought to curb greenhouse gases. The article adds that a lot more improvements are needed to the country's power grid before we can use all that wind power efficiently.

  <')((((((((><~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Hot Air Over Wind Power Project? 12.18.09

Picture
The windmills proposed off Cape Cod are getting yet more ink today over a local agency's decision to challenge the state over the bundle of permits needed for the clean energy project. This time the objection is not whether the project is clean. The objection is over a state decision to allow the developers of the wind farm to seek one approval from one agency for all the various local permits needed to get the project off the ground. Once again, both sides have a point: do we really want state government preempting local authority? In this case the windmills themselves will be in federal waters, while the power lines delivering the electricity will run across communities each with their own set of zoning laws governing such projects.


The point here is the hypocrisy. Or is the word disingenuous-ness? How much local say was there when Shoreham Nuclear Power plant was built and then scuttled on Long Island in NY? Where were the local environmental commissions and planners when Spectra Energy leveled a 670 mile swath of New England wilderness to deliver natural gas from Nova Scotia to Boston? How many dozens of towns did that pipeline cross through, wiping out sensitive forest wetlands.


Picture
Forest wetlands, a.k.a. Vernal Ponds are the unsung heroes of forest woodlands, Yet entire swathes of sensitive forest wetlands and uplands were neutered to accommodate these pipelines. Just below is a Google Earth image of a section of the pipeline where it runs through Boxford, MA. Note that there is an intersection in this image, so two swathes of woodlands were cleared here. If you ever get a chance, drive through Boxford, there's a reason it's some of the priciest real estate in Massachusetts. How much say did the Boxford Conservation Commission have over this destruction?


Back to the point. In terms of sum totals, how can the environmental impact of accommodating these windmill transmission lines even compare to Spectra Energy's 670-mile right-of-way, which is maintained like a country road.

This doesn't even address the long-term benefits derived from the windmills which are a renewable resource,. The gas pipeline delivers fossil fuels. Again, the argument that local folks should have a say in regional matters is a powerful one, but you have to wonder why it's gaining such traction here when historically huge power companies have gotten what they want regardless of local objections, thanks tin large part to federal support. The feds don't appear to be getting into this Cape Wind fray.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~><((((((((()'>